Rosemann, Michael, Recker, Jan C. ORCID: 0000-0002-2072-5792 and Vessey, Iris (2010). An examination of IS conference reviewing practices. Communications of the Association for Information Systems : CAIS, 26 (15). pp. 287-304. New York, NY: ACM. ISSN 1529-3181

Full text not available from this repository.
Link to the document:


There has been considerable interest over the years within the IS research community into how to shape articles for successful publication. Little effort has been made, however, to examine the reviewing criteria that make a difference to publication. We argue that, to provide better guidance to authors, more solid evidence is needed into the factors that contribute to acceptance decisions. This paper examines empirically the outcomes of the reviewing processes of three well-known IS conferences held in 2007. Our analyses reveal four major findings. First, the evaluation criteria that influence the acceptance/rejection decision vary by conference. Second, those differences can be explained in terms of the maturity and breadth of the specific conference of interest. Third, while objective review criteria influence acceptance/rejection decisions, subjective assessment on the part of the program committees may also play a substantial role. Fourth, while high scores on objective criteria are essential for acceptance, they do not guarantee acceptance. On the other hand, low scores on any criterion are likely to result in rejection.

Item Type: Journal Article
Recker, Jan
URN: urn:nbn:de:hbz:38-88237
Journal or Publication Title: Communications of the Association for Information Systems : CAIS
Publisher: ACM
ISSN: 1529-3181
Volume: 26
Number: 15
Subjects: Data processing Computer science
Management and auxiliary services
Uncontrolled Keywords:
editorial practicesEnglish
academic researchEnglish
Faculty: Faculty of Management, Economy and Social Sciences
Divisions: Weitere Institute, Arbeits- und Forschungsgruppen > Cologne Institute for Information Systems (CIIS)
Language: English
Date: April 2010
Related URLs:
Place of Publication: New York, NY
Refereed: Yes
Page Range: pp. 287-304


Downloads per month over past year


Actions (login required)

View Item View Item