Universität zu Köln

Something is Rotten in the State of Aggression Research: Novel Methodological and Theoretical Approaches to Research on Digital Games and Human Aggression

Elson, Malte (2014) Something is Rotten in the State of Aggression Research: Novel Methodological and Theoretical Approaches to Research on Digital Games and Human Aggression. PhD thesis, Universität zu Köln.

[img]
Preview
PDF
Available under License Creative Commons Attribution.

Download (2397Kb) | Preview

    Abstract

    This dissertation offers a comprehensive critique of the current state of research on violent game playing and aggressive outcomes. It discusses twenty-five years of research on violence in digital games and aggression, including empirical evidence, theoretical perspectives, and the heated debates in both the public and academia. The main focus here is on methodological issues limiting the conclusiveness of the research, particularly experiments conducted in psychological laboratories. By suggesting methodological advancements in the study of game violence effects, the thesis wants to offer new perspectives on digital games and aggression to move forward the field and the ideological debates that surround it. The thesis comprises a total of 5 peer-reviewed journal articles (of which 3 are published, one is accepted and in press, and one is under review) that include data from one original study and a secondary analyses of 3 further studies. The first part of the thesis consists of a detailed review of the current scientific literature on violent game effects with a focus on the theories that have been developed to explain the relationship between the use of digital games and aggression. Important theoretical shortcomings and fallacies of social-cognitive perspectives on how aggression is acquired through violent media contents are identified and discussed. The second part is a methodological critique of laboratory experiments in research on the effect of violent games. First, common problems and pitfalls in the manipulation of violence as an independent variable and improper control of relevant confounding factors are discussed. The modification of game content (“modding”) is suggested as a novel method to meet the requirements of rigorous internal validity and sufficient external validity in psychological laboratory experiments. The advantages of this method are illustrated by the results of an experiment in which it was used. This is followed by an examination of one of the most popular laboratory measures of aggressive behavior (the Competitive Reaction Time Task), providing evidence from three studies that the unstandardized use in the scholarly literature poses a threat to its interpretability and generalizability. The dissertation concludes with an analysis of the scientific discourse on the game violence-aggression link, and the ways in which it is shaped by ideological convictions that affect both the theoretical assumptions and the methodological procedures. This duality of ideologies present in theory and methods constitutes a threat to violent game effects research, as it causes the field to stagnate. It is argued that this stagnancy can only be resolved through methodological rigor that will, ultimately, advance inadequate theories of media effects.

    Item Type: Thesis (PhD thesis)
    Creators:
    CreatorsEmail
    Elson, Maltemail@malte-elson.com
    URN: urn:nbn:de:hbz:38-56884
    Subjects: Psychology
    Social sciences
    Uncontrolled Keywords:
    KeywordsLanguage
    digital games, mass media, aggression, violence, modding, modifications, methods, experiments, standardization, measurement, methodology, Competitive Reaction Time TaskEnglish
    Faculty: Humanwissenschaftliche Fakultät
    Divisions: Humanwissenschaftliche Fakultät > Department Psychologie
    Language: English
    Date: 09 April 2014
    Date Type: Publication
    Date of oral exam: 09 July 2014
    Full Text Status: Public
    Date Deposited: 12 Aug 2014 15:20:10
    Referee
    NameAcademic Title
    Bente, GaryProf. Dr.
    Ferguson, Christopher J.Prof. Dr.
    Stahl, JuttaProf. Dr.
    URI: http://kups.ub.uni-koeln.de/id/eprint/5688

    Actions (login required)

    View Item